Skip to Content

Is Your Anxiety All in Your Head? How to Identify “False Anxiety” Signals

Why Do I Feel Anxious for No Reason? The Hidden Link Between Gut Health and Panic

Stop treating just the mind. Discover how blood sugar, sleep, and inflammation trigger “false anxiety” in this deep dive into The Anatomy of Anxiety by Dr. Ellen Vora. Tired of fighting your own mind? Scroll down to decode your body’s hidden stress signals and finally find the calm you deserve.

Genres

Psychology, Health, Nutrition, Personal Development

Introduction: Learn to decode your anxiety.

The Anatomy of Anxiety (2022) challenges the conventional view that anxiety is solely a mental disorder. It proposes that many forms of anxiety originate from bodily imbalances rather than troubled thoughts. It offers actionable strategies for managing anxiety through lifestyle and diet adjustments, while also suggesting that some forms of anxiety can serve as helpful signals for achieving a more balanced life.

Anxiety has been part of the human experience since ancient times. The Roman philosopher Cicero wrote about it in 45 BC, describing it as a disorder of mind and body. In recent years, anxiety disorders have become increasingly prevalent, with approximately 300 million people worldwide affected. The United States, in particular, has seen a sharp rise in anxiety rates, with a 30 percent increase from 2008 to 2018.

Are you tired of feeling overwhelmed by anxiety? Do you long for a deeper understanding of your restless mind and a practical approach to finding calm? This summary offers a fresh perspective on anxiety, viewing it not just as a problem to solve, but as a potential guide to greater health and growth. You’ll learn the difference between “false” anxiety, rooted in physical imbalances, and “true” anxiety, which signals a need for deeper change.

Whether you’re grappling with occasional unease or chronic worry, this summary provides a roadmap to manage your anxiety and harness its potential for a more authentic, purposeful life.

Anxiety, true and false

In her practice, Ellen Vora takes a holistic approach to anxiety, moving away from strict diagnostic labels. She recognizes that anxiety manifests differently in each individual – from work-related stress to social unease, from constant worry to physical symptoms like dizziness or chest tightness.

Central to her treatment approach is the concept of “true” and “false” anxiety – terms she introduces to help patients better understand and address their experiences. False anxiety stems from physiological imbalances in the body. It might be triggered by something as simple as a blood sugar crash or a bout of gut inflammation. In these cases, the body sends stress signals to the brain, which then fabricates a narrative to explain the unease. This type of anxiety, while very real and often intensely painful, can often be addressed through lifestyle changes like diet modifications or improved sleep habits.

True anxiety, on the other hand, goes deeper. It’s rooted in our existential awareness of life’s inherent vulnerability and our mortality. This form of anxiety isn’t something to be eliminated but rather understood and harnessed. True anxiety can serve as an internal compass, guiding us toward what really matters. It might push us to confront uncomfortable truths, make important changes, or pursue paths more aligned with our values and abilities.

So Vora’s approach is to address false anxiety first. In doing so, you can clear the noise and better tune into the messages of your true anxiety. This approach encourages you to view anxiety not just as a disorder to be cured, but as a complex aspect of the human experience that, when properly understood, can lead to improved health, personal growth, and a deeper sense of purpose.

In the next section, we’ll look at two common sources of false anxiety: sleep and food.

Reclaim your natural rhythm

Sleep, that nightly ritual you probably take for granted, plays a bigger role in your mental health than you might think. It’s the unsung hero in your battle against anxiety, a powerful ally in maintaining mental health. The relationship between sleep and anxiety is two-way, each influencing the other. When you’re chronically sleep-deprived, you’re essentially inviting anxiety into your body. On the flip side, when anxiety takes up shop in you, it often brings along its troublesome friend, insomnia, with it.

It can be hard to get a good night’s sleep these days. A cacophony of artificial lights and electronic devices conspire to throw off your natural rhythm. Our ancestors relied on the sun to tell them when to wake and when to rest. Now we’ve got Netflix binges and doom-scrolling sessions keeping our bodies alert when they should be winding down.

But there are ways to reclaim your body’s natural rhythms, starting with embracing natural light. Try stepping out into the morning sunshine. This isn’t just a nice way to start the day, it also helps set your internal clock. And when evening rolls around, dim the lights and consider sporting some blue light-blocking glasses. Think of it as creating a sunset for your brain.

If you’re really struggling with sleep, you could try this rather unconventional solution: camping. Pitching a tent and spending a few nights under the stars can work wonders for resetting your circadian rhythm. It’s like pressing the factory reset button on your sleep-wake cycle. No artificial lights, no blaring alarm clocks – just you, nature, and the natural ebb and flow of light and darkness.

And when it comes to timing, research on hunter-gatherer societies finds that people typically go to sleep about three hours after sunset.

What you eat also has a big impact. Do you ever wake up in the middle of the night feeling inexplicably anxious? It’s probably as a result of your blood sugar. Nighttime sugar crashes cause a spike of cortisol and adrenaline that can jolt you awake, as well as give you nightmares. The fix? Consider a spoonful of almond butter before bed to help keep your blood sugar stable throughout the night, paving the way for uninterrupted, anxiety-free sleep.

The struggle to prioritize sleep in today’s world is so common that some cultures have coined specific terms for it. The Chinese concept of “revenge bedtime procrastination” refers to the behavior of staying up late scrolling through your phone or watching TV, not because you’re not tired, but because you’re subconsciously trying to reclaim some “me time” after a day of obligations. Recognizing this pattern can be the first step in addressing it and finding healthier ways to balance personal time and sleep.

In the end, good sleep isn’t just about logging hours in bed, you need to work with your body, not against it. With a little understanding and some tweaks to your habits, you can set yourself up for a calmer and more balanced mind.

Eating for calm

Have you ever noticed how a sugary treat can leave you feeling jittery and on edge an hour later? Or how a hearty, home-cooked meal can make you feel grounded and content? These aren’t coincidences. The connection between what you eat and how you feel runs deep.

Your body requires specific nutrients to function optimally – including to produce neurotransmitters, those chemical messengers that regulate your mood and anxiety levels. When you’re missing vital nutrients, your body sounds the alarm, triggering feelings of scarcity and unease. These can spiral into full-blown anxiety.

So what should you be eating? Picture a plate divided into quarters: one-quarter protein, one-quarter starch, and a full half dedicated to vegetables. You’re not counting calories or macros here, rather you’re ensuring that you’re providing your body with ample nutrients. Vegetables, in particular, are powerhouses of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that support brain function and help keep anxiety at bay.

When it comes to carbohydrates, the story isn’t as simple as “carbs are bad.” In fact, for many people struggling with anxiety, especially women of reproductive age, including carbs in their diet can bring relief. The key is to choose the right kind. Starchy vegetables like sweet potatoes, plantains, and squashes offer a steady supply of energy without putting you on the blood sugar roller coaster that refined carbs do. This consistent blood sugar can signal to your body that food is abundant, quieting the stress response that often masquerades as anxiety.

Fat, long vilified in diet culture, deserves a place of respect on your plate. For some, increasing the intake of certain healthy fats can be one of the quickest ways to improve anxiety symptoms. Focus on naturally occurring fats from sources like avocados, nuts, coconut, and well-raised animals. These fats are more recognizable to your body and less likely to provoke inflammation. On the flip side, industrial vegetable and seed oils, despite their healthy-sounding names, can be highly inflammatory and potentially harmful.

So what shouldn’t you eat? Highly processed foods, human-made fats like trans fats and margarine, and added sugars are the usual suspects. These modern food inventions can wreak havoc on your body, destabilizing blood sugar and promoting inflammation – both of which can exacerbate anxiety.

But make sure striving for dietary perfection doesn’t become its own source of stress. You don’t need to follow these guidelines flawlessly 100 percent of the time. Instead, make informed choices and do your best within the constraints of life.

Nourishing your body is, of course, about your physical health – but at the same time, you need to create a foundation for your mental well-being.

Getting stress out of your body

Imagine a rabbit frozen in fear as a wolf approaches. In an instant, its body decides: run, fight, or play dead. The rabbit goes limp, appearing lifeless. Once the danger passes, it shakes vigorously, discharging the pent-up stress from its body before hopping away. Note the last step – the release. Humans, faced with our own metaphorical wolves, often lack this. We try to power through, suppressing our bodies’ natural stress response, and then wonder why we feel perpetually on edge.

Your autonomic nervous system, your body’s unconscious regulator of arousal, plays a crucial role in this dance. It’s not as simple as an on-off switch between fight-or-flight and rest-and-digest. Recent research, known as polyvagal theory, paints a more nuanced picture. Beyond the sympathetic – your stress response – and parasympathetic – your relaxation response, there’s a third state: the dorsal vagal response, associated with immobilization and dissociation. This freeze state, while potentially lifesaving in extreme situations, can leave you feeling emotionally numb and hopeless when it’s chronically activated.

Interestingly, your stress response may also be influenced by your gender. While the fight-or-flight reaction has dominated research, studies now suggest a “tend-and-befriend” response is more common in females. This involves caregiving behaviors and seeking social connections for protection – an evolutionary adaptation that may have increased humans chances for survival.

So how can you break free from this cycle of unresolved stress? By resolving it – discharging it, like the rabbit. Movement, self-expression, and social connection offer pathways to discharge this pent-up energy. A vigorous dance session, a heartfelt conversation with a friend, or even a practice called shamanic shaking – deliberately moving your body to music in a free-form manner – can help reset your nervous system.

If you have a packed schedule, “microcizing” – brief bursts of movement throughout the day – can be helpful. A quick yoga flow between meetings or a brisk walk around the block can also work wonders.

You can’t eliminate stress entirely – that’s neither possible nor desirable. Instead, create space for your body to process and release tension naturally, much like other animals do.

So now that you know about false anxiety – that anxiety which comes from the body being out of a misalignment – it’s time to talk about a different kind of anxiety altogether.

Anxiety as a guide

What if your anxiety wasn’t a cage, but a compass? What if, properly tuned, anxiety helped you navigate and show you your path? This is true anxiety, that deep-seated unease that whispers “something’s off” when you’ve strayed from your authentic self – and gently – or sometimes not so gently – nudges you back on course.

Interpreting your anxiety can be tricky: it’s easy to misinterpret its message. You can think it’s screaming for more control when really, it’s urging you to loosen your grip. You white-knuckle your way through life, building fortresses of success and possessions, thinking you’re creating safety. But true safety – capital “S” Safety – isn’t found in the corner office or the perfect house. It’s in surrendering to the understanding that absolute control is an illusion.

When grief comes knocking – and it will – it can feel like the ground has disappeared beneath your feet. The loss of a loved one, a dream, a version of yourself – these experiences can leave you grasping for meaning in a world that’s suddenly become senseless. But pushing away the pain doesn’t make it disappear. It simply buries it, where it can fester and transform into physical ailments or unresolved trauma. A healthier path is to dive into the hurt. Feel it fully. Meet it with compassion. Let it wash over you like a wave, knowing that like all waves, it will eventually recede.

For the sensitive souls among us, this can feel particularly daunting. Your antenna is always up, picking up on the world’s pain and imperfections with great precision. But consider this: your sensitivity isn’t a weakness to be overcome. It’s a strength that allows you to feel the world’s truths more viscerally, to create more deeply, to love more fully. Yes, you might feel anxiety more acutely, but it also means you have a unique capacity to transform that anxiety into purposeful, meaningful action.

Conclusion

The main takeaway of this summary to The Anatomy of Anxiety by Ellen Vora is that anxiety isn’t a simple disorder, but rather has multiple meanings.

By distinguishing between false anxiety – stemming from physiological imbalances – and true anxiety – rooted in existential awareness – you can address immediate concerns through lifestyle changes while also harnessing anxiety as a guide toward personal growth.

To tackle false anxiety, focus on improving factors like sleep and nutrition, while learning to discharge stress in effective ways. Meanwhile, embrace true anxiety as a compass for authenticity and meaningful action. Once you’ve turned down the noise, your anxiety can be a useful signal guiding you to what matters.